What’s Really Causing Coral Bleaching?

The soft coral colony at the center of the picture is bleached. The corals to the right are not. (click for credit)

Coral are amazing animals. They live in a mutualistic relationship with algae, giving the algae a safe home in exchange for some of the food that the algae make through photosynthesis. The variety of colors seen in a coral reef are a result of this relationship. However, coral sometimes expel their algae, turning white. This is called “coral bleaching,” and it generally happens when the water is warmer than usual. the Australian Marine Conservation informs us:

Coral bleaching is a global crisis, caused by increased ocean temperatures driven by carbon pollution.

This has become a common mantra in the “global warming is going to kill us all” movement, because coral reefs are so fundamentally important to the health of ocean ecosystems. Indeed, it has become so important that if you question what the global-warming alarmists say, it can lead to dire consequences.

Consider, for example, the case of Dr. Peter Ridd. Some of his colleagues at James Cook University published work indicating that Australia’s Great Barrier Reef was on the verge of collapse because of global warming. Dr. Ridd dared to question that narrative, pointing out the data that indicate there is nothing unusual about the bleaching events that have been occurring at the Great Barrier Reef and that the reef has about the same amount of healthy coral as it did back in 1985. For that transgression, he was fired. While a court has ruled the firing unlawful, the university plans to appeal the ruling. Regardless of what happens at appeal, it is clear that the firing was anti-science. Criticism of data, even data related to sacred cows such as global warming, is the hallmark of good science. To squelch such criticism is a direct assault on the progress of science.

Of course, the real question is whether or not global warming is a threat to the oceans’ coral reefs. The answer remains unclear, but the balance of the evidence indicates that it is not. For example, one study of the Great Barrier Reef shows that bleaching events were more common several hundred years ago. According to that study, bleaching events hit their peak in the 1850s. There is also some indication that bleaching is an adaptive mechanism and is not necessarily bad for the health of a coral reef.

With all that in mind, consider a new study that looked at the Looe Key reef in the lower Florida Keys. The study examined all sorts of data related to coral and water conditions over three decades, and they found something rather interesting: high water temperatures were not enough to cause large amounts of coral bleaching. Since we know bleaching is tied to warm water temperatures, marine biologists define something called the “bleaching threshold,” which is when the water temperature reaches at least one degree above the monthly average for that region. It is thought that any temperature above the bleaching threshold can lead to a bleaching event.

Surprisingly, the researchers found that the bleaching threshold was exceeded many times, but there was rarely a mass-bleaching event. In fact, the only mass-bleaching events that occurred were when the bleaching threshold was exceeded AND there was a lot of runoff from the Everglades. Specifically, they found that when a bleaching event occurred, the amount of dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) and soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP) in the water had increased. Both DIN and SRP are elevated when there is an excessive amount of runoff.

Here is how the researchers put it:

Although water temperatures at Looe Key exceeded the 30.5 °C bleaching threshold repeatedly over the 3-decade study, the three mass bleaching events occurred only when DIN:SRP ratios increased following heavy rainfall and increased Everglades runoff.

So while warm water temperatures are necessary for coral bleaching, they weren’t the critical factor for Looe Key. Instead, the amount of water pollution was key. Please note that we already know sunscreen in the water can be very bad for coral larvae, so water quality is obviously a serious factor to consider when trying to protect the health of the ocean’s reefs.

Unfortunately, I don’t think the “global warming is going to kill us all” crowd will pay much attention to inconvenient data like these.

8 Comments

  1. Marshall says:

    I know this is a bit of a tangent, but given how much global warming has been in the news recently, do you have any recommended resources for reading more? I have appreciated your posts on the issue, especially those highlighting the negative feedback mechanisms that keep the climate stable. But I would like a broader overview of the subject, and it can be so difficult to know who to trust to be honest on this issue.

    1. Jay Wile says:

      One of the most reasonable voices on the issue is Dr. Judith Curry. She had to resign her university position because she wouldn’t toe the party line on climate change. Her integrity on the issue is impressive. Her blog adds much-needed realism to the climate-change issue. Although he doesn’t write a lot for the general public, Dr. Richard Lindzen is also a serious climate scientist who addresses the data instead of the hype. Another good voice is Dr. Roy Spencer, probably the world’s foremost authority on satellite measurements of global temperature.

  2. red says:

    Talking heads completely miss reality. Thank you for writing this, it was a good read, informative, and I still don’t know whether to laugh or cry. I remember imams using lies like this, the global warming scam, to incite followers to violence. niio

  3. Alaska Nivanuatu says:

    This study doesn’t seem like something with which global warming/climate change doomsdayers would necessarily disagree, because the conclusion could be drawn that this study indicates that the overall cause of coral bleaching is pollution: a combination of air pollution (carbon pollution causing the warming water) and water pollution, which of course are both caused by humans and must be stopped at all costs!

  4. John D says:

    Watching an episode of Nova on the Dead Sea and found it interesting that a scientist speaking on the local coral mentioned that the coral reef in the Red Sea is the only reef in the world that has not experienced bleaching.

    1. Jay Wile says:

      I think that might be a local phenomenon. I know there have been bleaching events in the Red Sea. Perhaps there is a part of the Red Sea where bleaching hasn’t been seen.

  5. John D says:

    Ahh yes. You’re correct. Apparently only the Northern Red Sea. Gulf of Aqaba.

    https://m.phys.org/news/2019-02-northern-red-sea-coral-reefs.html

    They state it’s due to an evolution event… Whats your take?

    1. Jay Wile says:

      It’s a lot of story telling, but it is plausible. However, it’s also possible that bleaching is an adaptive response to warming, where the coral eject algae (not plants as written in the link) to get algae that are more active in warmer waters. It’s possible that the algae in the Northern Red Sea are active at a wide range of temperatures, so there is no need for ejection.

%d bloggers like this: